Skip to content
About City First Insurance

Get a Quote




About City First Insurance

Insurance is the most important foundation for making sure your financial house is in order. When most people add up all the different insurance bills they pay, insurance is the second largest bill in their household, right behind their mortgage! Yet most people don’t really know what they are paying for. Our educational approach is designed to change this trend.

Let us help! We take the time to educate you on insurance coverages so that you are confident that you have chosen your best option whether it is for your car, home, or your life.

We will shop your insurance coverage with over a dozen top-rated insurance companies to make sure you are getting the best deal for you!

Our Team

Cheryl Potter

Cheryl Potter

Agency Administrator/Agent


Phone: 801-960-3705

Fax: 385-351-5971

Cheryl.potter@city1st.com


Mitch Potter

Mitch Potter

New Client Specialist/Agent


Phone: 801-335-6493

Mitch.potter@city1st.com


Mackae Potter

Mackae Potter, LUTCF

President/Managing Partner

Life and Investment Specialist


Phone: 801-564-5480

Mackae.potter@city1stinsurance.com

24 years insurance industry veteran of which 22 years has been spent managing agencies as well as recruiting and training insurance agents.

Start Carrier

See more

  • AIG
  • American Modern
  • Athene
  • Burns & Wilcox
  • Catcoverage
  • CNA
  • Dairyland
  • Encompass
  • Foremost
  • Foresters Financial
  • Foxpoint
  • Gerber
  • Global Atlantic
  • Hagerty
  • Kemper
  • Met Life
  • Mission Select
  • Mutual of Omaha
  • Nationwide
  • Pacific Specialty